Archive for Main Stage Production

Congratulations to the cast of Catch Me If You Can!

Thank you to the performers who auditioned for OLT’s upcoming production of Catch Me If You Can! We saw some extraordinary talent, which made casting very difficult. Congratulations to those cast!

Frank Abagnale Jr.- Scott Richard

Carl Hanratty- Chris Zika

Frank Abagnale Sr.- Keith S. White

Paula Abagnale- Emily Locklear

Brenda Strong- Hannah Schroeder

Carol Strong- Randi Seffinger

Roger Strong- Brian George


Brianna Ascione, Gianna-Leigh Bastar, Tyler Donovan, Paige Erdmann, Robert Falco, Hannah Federman, Chris Gatterdam, Olivia Gonzales, Shannon Lombardi, Michelle McMillan, Shayna Rives, Gwen Vigorito

We are additionally searching for performers fitting the following descriptions to round out the cast. If you are interested in performing, please contact us at
Male Ensemble Dancers: Seeking strong singers/dancers for ensemble numbers as well as ensemble roles.
Age Range: 18-35
Voice Type: Baritone/Tenor

Adult Male Ensemble: Seeking a strong singer and actor to portray multiple roles in the show.
Age Range: 35-55
Voice Type: Baritone

Female Ensemble Dancer: Seeking one additional female ensemble dancer. Must be a strong singer and dancer. Will be used heavily in all ensemble numbers as well as play some ensemble roles.
Age Range: 18-35
Voice Type: Alto/Soprano Belt


This July, we’re asking you to CASH US IF YOU CAN!

We’ve turned over our 50th Anniversary fundraising campaign to our upcoming production of Catch Me If You Can. We’d love your help raising the necessary funds to add musicians to the pit orchestra for this production. What can you help us raise in 30 days? The sky’s the limit!


Pippin Tickets

Old Library Theatre’s production of Pippin will have a six performance run from July 28th to August 6th! Performances are at 8 p.m. on July 28th and 29th, as well as August 4th and 5th, and 2 p.m. on July 30th and August 6th. Purchase your tickets at On the Stage: Pippin today!

Congratulations to the cast of Children of Eden!

Thank you to the performers who auditioned for OLT’s upcoming production of Children of Eden! We saw some extraordinary talent, which made casting very difficult. Congratulations to those cast!

Father- Pedro Jimenez
Adam- Aaron Noriega
Eve- DeAnna Choi
Cain- Brian Levario
Abel- Hunter Halliwell
Seth- Matt Cavallo
Noah- Noah Brendemuhl
Mama- Evan Charpentier
Japeth- Bobby Snyder
Yonah- Natasha Gaston
Ham- Ryan Green
Aysha- Matrika Hay
Aphra- Kaitlyn Gandolfi
Shem/ Snake (Baritone)- Manny Dunn
Aidan Mascoli- Abel’s Death Solo
Snake (Alto)/ Generations Solo- Evianna Hawkins
Snake (Tenor)/ Generations Solo- Nick Wager
Snake (Mezzo)/ Storyteller- Allison Macri
Snake (Soprano)/ Wasteland Soloist- Cina Gabel
Wasteland Soloist- Matt Cordero
Wasteland Soloist- Alexa Jimenez
Storyteller- Danielle Bouie
Storyteller- Lisa Kosak
Storyteller- Tabitha Spitz
Storyteller- Tara Perrothers
Storyteller- Leah Feingold
Storyteller- Roger Manzano
Storyteller- Eric Robitaille
Storyteller- Christian Spinella

“Noises Off”

Noises Off tickets are now available! Follow the link below to purchase tickets:

On the Stage: Noises Off

Tickets can also be purchased by calling 973-658-4420. Noises Off runs March 10th and 11th at 8 p.m. and March 12th at 2 p.m.

Congratulations to the cast of Aida!

Thanks to all who auditioned for our upcoming Main stage production of Aida, and special congratulations to the cast:Aida

Aida– Sierra Hunter

Radames – Rob Ryan

Amneris – Ali Rose Harton

Zoser – Gary Lizardo

Mereb – Hamadi Price

Nehebka – Ashley Seldon

Amonasro – Jesse Simpson

Pharoah – Tomo Lovric


Ensemble Men:

Devin Hall

Fred Carlton

Jesse Simpson (also Amonasro)

Bobby Snyder

Chris Gatterdam

Pedro Jiminez

David Yurch

Burl Bishop Rogers

Mark Anthony Lucky

Elmer Cruz

Joe Love Seong


Ensemble Women:

MJ Son

Heather Hussey

A’ja Desormeau

Dana Patrice

So Young Jeon

Tiffany Stewart

Alice Allen

Brittany Bethea

Evianna Hawkins

Allison Miller


Brick – Craig Tiede
Mae – Mary Claire Bongiovanni
Head Maid – Michelle Thomas-Hanson
Butler – Burl “Bishop” Rogers
Margaret – Elisabeth Gelinas
Big Mamma – Cynthia Smith Barry
Big Daddy – Jak Prince
Dr. Baugh – James Gwyn
Gooper – Eric Parkin
Rev. Tooker – Matthew Haines
Kids – Carina DiMaggio, Adelaide Prekopa, Eliza Prekopa, Rachel Rives, Justin Roth


For information on discounted tickets, Become A Friend Today!

2016 OLT Subscription Brochure_Page_1_sm


Here is the cast of The Great American Trailer Park Musical set to open July 24th. Congratulations!

Jeannie Garstecki – Evan Tintle Charpentier
Norbert Garstecki – Michael Ferentinos
Pippi – Brianna Morris
Duke – Brendan Hall
Betty – Maureen McNulty
Lin – Samantha Kaplan
Pickles – Andrea Thibodeau


Old Library Theatre is seeking submissions from individuals interested in directing a show during our upcoming 2016 season. Candidates must complete the Director Submission Form by July 1. For additional information, consult our Submission Instructions. Proposals are being accepted for Main Stage Productions, Minor Productions, Youth Productions and Reader’s Theater Productions – submit yours today!